🏷️ Dishes/Highlights
Seafood - Mahi Sandwich - Grouper - Crab Chowder - Conch Fitters - sandwiches
📋 Menu
Appetizers
Conch Fritters
$13
With cocktail sauce
Shrimp Kaboom
$15
Fried with KaBoom sauce
Buffalo Shrimp
$15
Coconut Shrimp
$15
Calamari
$16
Fresh from the docks of Maine. Served with Thai chili dipping sauce
Dragon Green Beans
$11
Sandbar Sliders
$16
Beef & chorizo sliders on Hawaiian rolls
Tuna Sashimi
$15
Sushi-grade tuna, blackened, served with wasabi & ginger
Smoked Fish Dip
$13
Fisherman's Soups
Stone Crab Chowder
Cup $7 Bowl $11
Lobster Bisque
Cup $7 Bowl $11
Salads
Grapefruit Salad
$12
Grapefruit wedges, avocado, toasted walnuts, mixed greens and Key lime honey vinaigrette
Wedge Salad
$12
Iceberg, red onions, bleu cheese crumbles, tomatoes and bacon
Spanish Salad
$11
Iceberg, artichoke hearts, fried capers, red onions, and roasted red peppers, with golden Italian dressing
Caesar Salad
$10
Romaine, house-made Caesar dressing, garlic croutons
House Salad
$9
Mixed greens and assorted veggies
Menu
Add Steak
$12
Add Shrimp
$10
Add Mahi
$10
Add Tuna
$10
Lunch Break
Craig's Famous Fish Sandwich
$19
Fried mahi, with tomato, American cheese, house made tartar on wheat bread
Tavernier Fish Sandwich
$17
Grilled mahi, lettuce, tomato, onion, on a Kaiser roll
Shrimp Po' Boy
$17
Fried shrimp, slaw, pico de gallo and KaBoom sauce on a hoagie
Key Largo Fish Tacos
$16
Corn tortillas, slaw, shredded cheese, baja sauce, & pico de gallo
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
$15
Chicken breast fried and topped with Provolone and Buffalo sauce
Cheeseburger In Paradise
$18
Angus Beef ½ pound burger, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion
French Dip
$17
Shaved prime rib, horseradish sauce, provolone cheese, & au jus
Fresh Catch
Catch Of The Day
$28
Only fresh local fish prepared grilled, blackened, fried, onion encrusted, jalapeño encrusted, piccata, or captain's style (add $2). Ask your server about upgrading to a premium fish.
Gone Fishin'
Whole Fried Snapper
$32
Whole fried fish served with Thai chili dipping sauce
Shrimp Scampi
$26
Jumbo shrimp, garlic, butter, scallions, and mushroom, over pasta or rice
Key Lime Seafood
$30
Shrimp, mahi, and calamari, with tomatoes & scallions, in a Key lime butter sauce over pasta or rice
Jumbo Shrimp
$28
Grilled, blackened or fried with your choice of side
Pick Two Fried Basket
$26
Fish, Calamari, Shrimp, (or double up on one) with fries & Tartar
Reef & Beef
Reef & Beef
$40
Churrasco steak topped with sautéed shrimp and chimichurri
Churrasco Steak
$32
Skirt steak marinated and grilled and served with chimichurri
Filet Mignon Certified
$48
8 oz center cut certified angus beef, with Madagascar peppercorn sauce. Add shrimp $9
Chicken
Chicken Finger Platter
$18
Chicken breast cut into strips and fried golden brown
Captain's Chicken
$22
Chicken breast breaded and baked with tomatoes, scallions, parmesan and Key lime butter
Bird On The Bayou Pasta
$19
Grilled chicken in a spicy Alfredo sauce over pasta
Captain's Favorites
Grilled Cheese
$6
Cheeseburger
$9
Grilled Shrimp
$9
Chicken Fingers
$8
Fish Fingers
$10
Sides
Fries
Rice
Mashed Potatoes
Green Beans
Cole Slaw
🕐 Hours
Mon
11am-9pm
Tue
11am-9pm
Wed
11am-9pm
Thu
11am-9pm
Fri
11am-9pm
Sat
11am-9pm
Sun
11am-9pm
Hours may vary for holidays. Confirm directly with the restaurant.
Is this menu out of date or information incorrect? Help the community!
ℹ️ Info
Address90154 Overseas Hwy, Tavernier, FL
Phone305-852-9424
City
Islamorada →
Deals
Deals & Specials →
SocialView Page ↗
📊 All-Time Stats
#37
Most Liked in Islamorada
457
total likes
🏆 Top in Islamorada