👍 #17 Most Liked · 1,396 Likes #140 This Month

Shortstop Deli

200 W Seneca St, Ithaca, NY 607-273-1030

🏷️ Dishes/Highlights

Cheesesteak - Buffalo Chicken Sub - Turkey Sub - Breakfast Sandwiches All Day - Bagels - Pizza Subs

📋 Menu

Sandwiches

The P.M.P. (The Original, Poor Man's Pizza) $8.99

See Order Sheet for Sandwich Descriptions

The P.M.P. (The Original, Poor Man's Pizza) - Grand Slam $11.99

See Order Sheet for Sandwich Descriptions

The W.G.C. (PMP on Garlic Bread)

See Order Sheet for Sandwich Descriptions

The M.B.C. $9.99

See Order Sheet for Sandwich Description

The M.B.C. - Grand Slam $12.99

See Order Sheet for Sandwich Description

The Sep-Pep

See Order Sheet for Sandwich Description

The C.S.C. $10.99

See Order Sheet for Sandwich Description

The C.S.C. - Grand Slam $13.99

See Order Sheet for Sandwich Description

The Sui (Soo-ee)

See Order Sheet for Sandwich Description

The Little Sicillian $11.49

See Order Sheet for Sandwich Description

The Little Sicillian - Grand Slam $14.29

See Order Sheet for Sandwich Description

The Big Willie $12.49

Created by Willie D, CU. For those with a big appetite. See Order Sheet for Sandwich Description

The Big Willie - Grand Slam $15.29

Created by Willie D, CU. For those with a big appetite. See Order Sheet for Sandwich Description

Add-Ons

Add Meat Toppings $1.50

Bacon, ham, meatballs, pepperoni, or ground sausage

Add Meat Toppings - Grand Slam $2.00

Bacon, ham, meatballs, pepperoni, or ground sausage

Add Veggies $1.25

All unlimited. Black olives, onions, lettuce, mushrooms, tomatoes, and sweet or hot peppers

Free Extras

Mayo, truck sauce, hot sauce, garlic, mustard, and crushed red pepper

Beverages

Fountain Soda $0.94

With any sandwich

Hot Pizza Subs

The PMP

On Baked French Bread with Marinara Sauce, shredded Mozzarella and a sprinkle of oregano

The WGC

The PMP on Baked Garlic Bread

The Sep-Pep

The WGC with Pepperoni and mushrooms

The MBC

The PMP with crushed meatballs

The CSC

The PMP with chopped Chicken Breast

The SUI

On Baked Garlic Bread; Marinara Sauce, Ground Italian-Sausage, Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Shredded Mozzarella and a sprinkle of oregano

The Little Sicillian

The PMP loaded with Meatballs, Ground-Sausage, Onions, Hot Sauce and Hot-n-Heavy (Garlic & Crushed Red peppers)

The Big Willie

The PMP with Swiss cheese added, Chopped Chicken, Bacon, Onions, Lettuce & Truck Sauce

Breakfast

Egg-Patty Only $4.50

Before 10:01am $3.00

Egg-Patty & Cheese $5.00

no meat. Before 10:01am $3.50

Egg & Meat $4.99

no Cheese. Before 10:01am $3.15

Egg With Meat And Cheese $5.95

Before 10:01am $4.45. Add Veggies ($0.65), Extra Cheese ($0.74), Extra Meat or Egg ($0.99)

Ss Potato Tots $5.25

Ss Cheesy Bread Stix $6.75

Served hot and Cheesy

Bagels $1.69

or English Muffin. Add Butter (+$0.50), Peanut Butter & Jelly, Sliced Cheese, or Cream Cheese

Pizza Bagels $7.25

add Ground-Sausage or Pepperoni (+$1.50 or +$0.75)

Sandwiches And Subs

Pepperoni Sandwich $6.99

Virginia Baked Ham BLT $6.99

bacon, lettuce, & tomato

Genoa Salami $6.99

Egg Salad $6.99

Veggie Sandwich $6.99

hummus

Italian-Mix $9.99

ham, pepperoni & salami

Turkey Breast $9.99

Roast Beef $9.99

Tuna Salad $9.99

Corned Beef $9.99

Pastrami $9.99

Cheese Sandwich $12.99

Seitan Teriyaki $12.99

vegan

Chicken Breast $12.99

regular, buffalo, bbq

Chicken Salad $12.99

Hot Bbq Beef $12.99

Hot Meatball $12.99

Reuben $10.95

Ithaca Cheese Steak $13.95

Dinosaur Bbq Pulled Pork $16.95

Bagels

Plain

Sesame Seed

Poppy Seed

Onion

Everything

Cinnamon-Raisin

Grain Bagel

Garlic Gluten Free Bread $0.50

English Muffin

Kaiser Roll

Wraps

Butter

Toasted or not toasted

Cream Cheese

Toasted or not toasted

Peanut Butter

Grape jelly, STW jelly

Ketchup

Hot Breakfast Sandwiches

Bacon

Choice of American cheese, Swiss cheese, Cheddar cheese, or Mozzarella cheese

Sausage

Choice of American cheese, Swiss cheese, Cheddar cheese, or Mozzarella cheese

Ham

Choice of American cheese, Swiss cheese, Cheddar cheese, or Mozzarella cheese

Turkey Bacon

Choice of American cheese, Swiss cheese, Cheddar cheese, or Mozzarella cheese

Scrambled Egg Patty

Choice of American cheese, Swiss cheese, Cheddar cheese, or Mozzarella cheese

Sandwich Type

Chicken Breast

Regular or Buff or BBQ

Bbq Pulled Pork

Ithaca Ch Steak

S.S. Reuben

Hot Meatball

Pastrami

Corned Beef

Turkey Breast

Roast Beef

Baked Ham

Salami

Egg Salad

Tuna Salad

Chicken Salad

Pepperoni

Bread Type

French

Italian

W.W. French

Kaiser Roll

Ciabatta

Rye

Sliced White

Sliced Wheat

Wrap

Gluten Free $0.50

Gluten Free Slice White

Gluten Free Sliced Wheat

Dressing

Mayonnaise

Miracle Whip

Yellow Mustard

Brown Mustard

Honey Mustard

Oil & Vinegar

Ranch

Russian

Bleu Cheese

Hot Sauce

BBQ Sauce

Butter

Pizza Sauce

Ketchup

Horseradish

Toppings

Lettuce

Tomatoes

Onions

Black Olives

Cucumbers

Sweet Pickles

Dill Pickles

Hot Peppers

Italian Mixed

Sweet Peppers

Mushrooms

Cole Slaw

Carrots

Salt Pepper

Cheese

American

Swiss

Provolone

Cheddar

Mozzarella

Extras

Regular Bacon

Turkey-Bacon

Pepperoni

Hummus

Seitan

Vegan

Cheese Only

Hummus Only

Specials

Meal Deal Combo $16.00

Sandwich or Sub with Pepsi

Pepsi $0.79

16 oz.

Pepsi $1.09

24 oz.

Pepsi $1.59

32 oz.

🚗 Delivery & Reservations

Order delivery or pickup

Order delivery or pickup

🕐 Hours

Mon 7am-8pm

Tue 7am-8pm

Wed 7am-8pm

Thu 7am-8pm

Fri 7am-8pm

Sat 10am-8pm

Sun 10am-8pm

Hours may vary for holidays. Confirm directly with the restaurant.

Is this menu out of date or information incorrect? Help the community!

ℹ️ Info

Address 200 W Seneca St, Ithaca, NY

Phone607-273-1030

City Ithaca →

Deals Deals & Specials →

SocialView Page ↗

📊 All-Time Stats

#17

Most Liked in Ithaca

1,396

total likes

🏆 Top in Ithaca

All Ithaca Restaurants →

🏷️ Browse Restaurant Deals & Specials →